|
Surviving the island of grace,
Thomas
Dunne Books, 2002
Chapter seven: Killing and Eating
We are going hunting today. It
is early, just light,
the fog still threads
the air, lisping over the calm waters. It is hard to get up,
and the two of us, my husband, Duncan, and I briefly
reconsider, knowing we could go tomorrow or the next day or
the next, but this morning is calm, and we will need meat
soon. There’s not much preparation, just dress warmly, pull on
hip boots and life jackets over our coats, check the gas tank,
get the rifle, pull the skiff in, start the engine, and we
will be hunting. It is hunting mostly in the sense of looking
very carefully as we parallel the shoreline, eyes skinning the
beach for the stray deer or two who have wandered down to
munch on kelp and sea-greens. Or sometimes we will see whole
herds, huge bachelor packs of thirty to seventy that rove the
long beaches, ganglike, moving from island to lagoon to the
mainland over to the other side of the bay.
They are Sitka
black-tailed deer, not native to Kodiak Island, but brought
here in 1924 from southeast Alaska. They are plentiful,
having no natural predators other than man, so much so that
some years the hunting limit in the bush is seven per person.
They are more beautiful than their cousins, the mule deer I
knew back East, delicate beyond just deer-ness, because of
their size. They are often no bigger than a goat. The hoof of
a big buck would easily fit in my hand.
When we are settled in
our skiff, we decide to go down to a long several-mile
stretch of beach not too far from our island. The ocean is a
pool this morning, and as we zip through it, I can see myself
leaping in like a silver fish, all point and no splash. But
when we arrive, there is a swell, as usual. It can be
tin-pan flat everywhere else, but action is always guaranteed
on this beach. We skim the shoreline and see a fox slinking
around a rocky stretch we know is good for clams, and farther
down, we see otter lounging among the kelp beds, but no deer.
We decide to go farther, down around Rocky Point, where we
seldom go because our sixteen foot skiff feels so small and
the waters so big below the two thousand foot cliffs. It’s a
dry run there too, and we start back, scanning the long
beachline one last time as we head home when we see them.
About eight deer, all bucks, headed down the beach as if on
some kind of schedule. They hear us and watch as we slow to
change positions in the skiff, with me now at the forty-horse
outboard, Duncan poised in the bow with his gun, ready to jump
out onto the sand. The surf is not too heavy, but I am
anxious at the sequence I know must follow: getting in just
right, just close enough for him to leap, then reversing full
throttle stern-first through the breakers without taking on
too much water.
Duncan is ashore and I am
back out in stiller water, watching, catching up on breath.
He stands on the beach, quiet, rifle in hand, while the
deer, too, watch. The ones we want are out in the open. He
drops to his knee , aims, fires. The herd runs, wildly, and
Duncan has just moments to squeeze off a few more shots as
they scatter, leaping up the cliffbank to the dense brush
above. Seven have run, one is down.
My turn. Nervously, I
throttle low and ease the bow back into the surge and break,
while Duncan stands there with the deer heavily draped over
his shoulders. He catches the sink of a wave and rolls the
body off into the skiff as it dips before him. We do it
again, and then we are on the way home, the two deer in the
bottom of the skiff, still dainty, graceful even in death,
while blood pools at our feet.
*
* * *
Hunting season in New
Hampshire was for us a time of war and near mourning. A
week before the opening, my mother would tramp the boundaries
of her land, the several hundred acres of woods and fields in
central New Hampshire, posting the largest neon-orange “NO
HUNTING!” signs she could find. We lived surrounded by woods
and forests, grew huge gardens, had chickens and goats, but we
never ate our animals, except once---Harry and Larry, two pigs
we guiltily fattened through one winter. At the last, my
mother balked at the slaughter and released us all from the
deed, hiring it out instead, the whole thing, from live pigs
to packages in the freezer. She hated the hunting and killing
of any animal, but saved her greatest scorn for deer hunters.
They would come, park
their trucks along the dirt road, and for several weeks we
would walk about in fear, fear of being shot, fear of letting
the dog out, whose fawn- colors would surely lure a bullet.
If we dared a walk at all, per mother’s instructions, we kept
to the road, wore loud red, and sang and talked as if with
megaphones to advertise our presence. Hunters were our
enemies. Every newspaper story of a hunting accident was read
aloud and we all would shake our heads at the tragedy,
murmuring, “What else could you expect? They were hunting.”
Occasionally we would hear a distant gunshot, and then we
knew all our cautions and fears were justified. Even more
occasionally, we would see a truck emerge from the woods with
a deer in the back--- crumpled, neck broken, legs splayed.
Even so, I could see its magnificence, and I was angry.
*
* * *
Part of the reason I came
to Alaska in 1978 and to this island was to become a
commercial fisherman, as my new husband had been all the
summers of his life. Blood was there from the start of my
trying-on of this new country. Kodiak was then and still is
the second most productive fishing port in the nation. There
are so many salmon here that last season, 1998, the canneries
shut down in the middle of the run because they had run out of
materials. So many salmon another year, the price went down
to a penny a pound.
The first year in the
skiff, I was startled to see how disconnected I felt from
these creatures. I pulled them from the nets, often
already dead, sometimes still alive. I studied them
incessantly, how their mouths gaped, their gills straining in
the strangulation of air. They made gurgling sounds, and often
flayed about in a final thrash toward the life of water. All
of this I recognized as desperate efforts to live, and yet I
was not moved to pity. It only stuck me how entirely
dissimilar we were: they so cold, cauled in gurry, limbless,
eyes unblinking, mute. Beyond all of this, I knew they were on
their way to die, nearly all of them, the millions that swarm
Alaska’s waters, headed kamikaze for the streambed and
spawn-out and a horrible, leprous, rotting kind of death. Yet
now, still, so beautiful, so obviously and purposefully
created, so deliberately fashioned with skin like a suit of
mail, the fit on fit of scale to scale. I stood in them
knee-, sometimes thigh-deep, these dead and dying and bloodied
creatures, all the while loving the artistry of their
bodies, and feeling happy to have caught them, that their
lives ended here in my boat. There it was, beauty and death
and food and grace clotted together.
*
* * *
We make sure that the
bucks are dead. A beach-hunting trip two years before had
taught us this caution. We were returning home with a
good-sized buck when the animal began to stir.
Just a leg at first. Muscle
spasms, I remember thinking. Then it began shaking its head;
then it lifted its head, kicking as it tried to stand. Duncan
and I looked at each other, horrified. "Sit on him!" he
yelled. Without hesitating, I jumped down hard on his neck
and straddled his chest. Still unbelieving, I looked his body
over carefully from my prime seat and realized there was no
blood to be seen anywhere, just a knick in his antlers. As he
struggled beneath me to rise, we ran through our options in
short, breathy phrases. We were still ten minutes from home.
If I let him up, he could do serious damage with his
adrenaline-powered hooves. Someone could easily be knocked
overboard. It was too risky to try and shoot him in the
skiff. There was only one choice, it seemed. I would hold
him down until we got to the island, and we would let him out
there. At that point, I longed for Duncan to offer to trade
places, but a switch, however equitable or chivalrous, was not
possible. I rode the bucking deer all the way back to the
island. As the beach came to view, Duncan aimed for the
softest sand, and gassed the engine. We braced for the hit,
jerked to a stop further up the beach than I'd ever been in a
skiff. I rolled off the deer and with one leap he was out, up
the beach and gone.
These two deer do not
surprise, though I watch them warily, expectantly. When we
return to the island, we slice open their throats and angle
their heads downhill, to bleed him as best we can. Duncan
removes the scent glands on the backs of the legs. Now the
gutting; for me, the worst part. Though there is something
very primitive about it, still, it is done with delicacy. It
is a form of reverse surgery, our care with the knives and
incisions not for the sake of the animal but for us and the
good of the meat. The intestines, bladder, scent glands, and
stomach must not be punctured or the foul gas and bacteria
will contaminate the meat. Deftly yet cautiously Duncan
severs the membranes holding the organs to the cavity, then at
the last, I squat down and pull out the bulging stomach and
ropes of intestines, still warm. The hearts and livers we
save. The rest of the entrails must be remove from the
scene as quickly as possible so as not to attract bears. .
Duncan has brought the ATV over, and, lacking a trailer of any
kind, has tied a piece of plywood tied on behind for a
makeshift trailer. With both hands, I grasp the slippery,
gelatinous organs and slide them over onto the plywood. They
ooze to the edges of the plywood and we realize there’s no way
they’ll stay on for the five hundred foot downhill run out to
the spit, where the tide will carry them away. I say I will do
it. Using my body as a shield, I kneel on the plywood, spread
my arms to engulf the steaming viscera, my face just inches
from its mass. And we are off roaring down the hill, going too
fast, the plywood, the guts, my own splayed arms and legs
rattling over rocks, logs, wanting only to get there, and to
keep my face out of it. It is nasty. As we land on the
beach, I am shaken and my hands are bleeding from gripping
the splintered edge of the plywood. I need a minute to catch
my breath before pulling these parts of the deer I now know so
well into the water. The saltwater stings my raw hands with a
purifying bite, and I hope I will not have to ride the
entrails of any other animal again. It is far too personal.
* *
* *
I see deer often during
the summer. The swim to our island and leave again at will,
perhaps searching for more grazing or more plentiful water.
Last night I went for a walk with my two-year old son, Elisha.
He rode on my hip as we wound toward Lupine Meadow and points
beyond. Around the first corner we saw a deer on the hillside
above us. She was intent on grazing, and though there was no
path and the slope was steep, I was drawn to her. Elisha clung
to me as I scrambled up the scree. We did not whisper or try
to sneak. She saw us. “Elisha, what is the deer eating?”
“Gas!” he proclaimed. “Yes, grass and look, what else?” I
asked to keep his eyes ahead instead of below as I continued
to climb. “Gowers. Deer eating gowers,” he said with the
same delight I felt as I watched her snap the tops of the
yellow coastal paintbrushes. Finally we were within ten feet
of her. She stopped for a moment, lifted her head, regarded
us with some interest, still chewing vigorously, and finding
no cause for alarm, went back to her berry bushes and
paintbrushes. We could have touched her with just a lunge.
I have nearly touched many deer over the years. They do not
act like any wild animal I have ever known. Their unconcern
for our presence does not serve them well.
One fall morning, just a
few days after the deer season opened, we were finishing
breakfast and saw what looked like a covey of ducks, very
large ducks, all swimming in an orderly row, but with strange
heads. They came closer, about thirty of them, and then I
could see they were not ducks, but deer. It was my first
sighting of a water-borne herd. They were swimming across
from another island about a mile away. They were remarkably
buoyant and obviously very experienced in such crossings. And
though the island was obviously inhabited, our red cabins
could be seen for half a mile, still, they were steering
directly for our beach. As their hooves touched ground, they
gingerly stepped ashore, still together, and began all of
them, walking quite calmly toward the house and us as we stood
on the porch, watching. Just outside our door, as they
walked past, Duncan just as calmly got his gun, lay in
position, we chose the two bucks we wanted, and like that,
it was done: our hunt for the year, our supply of deer meat
was provided. There was no sport in it, and that was good.
The pursuit of an animal held no thrill or fun for either of
us. I was pleased that it was done, but I hated it, too, and
wished they had come ashore somewhere else, or had at least
fled from us in the two-legged bound of fear. Let them at
least know who we are.
*
* * *
My first season in Alaska brought not only fish and deer, but
cattle. My father-in-law was a rancher on Kodiak Island for
thirty years. Every year of it was a skirmish. DeWitt’s
federal grazing lease of thirty-two thousand acres bordered
what he came to call the “bear hatchery,” a federal refuge
protecting the Kodiak bear, a huge subspecies of the grizzly.
The cattle, open-grazing in steep valleys and hillsides, had
no defense against the predator save a panicked gallop that
didn’t even wind the bear. Two years before I joined the
family, he loaded a herd of twenty onto a barge and out to
the island I live on every summer—Harvester Island. Though
the island is named for a sailing ship “The Harvester” that
ran aground near the turn-of-the century, the name fits our
fishing and hunting lives here well. On Harvester, he
reckoned, they would be safe from bears, and so they have
been. The herd has flourished, nearly doubling in size, fed
only by the grasses and greens of this place. These cattle
feed twelve of us in the extended family all through the year,
and feed twenty-eight through four months of the fishing
season. Every fall, we choose two or three animals to be
culled. Every fall, I stand for three days with the others
parsing flesh into portions and packages. This is part of the
business of living out, the business of ranching, and of
commercial fishing. This is what it costs to live here, and
this is how we feed so many. That is how I think of it when
the gun comes out. The beef is good---lean, sometimes tough,
but grass-fed natural. The deer, though, are better. And
so, the truth is told: we eat beef out of need; we eat deer
out of desire.
*
* * *
Now that the deer are gutted, they are lighter, and we carry
them easily into the warehouse that stores our skiffs in the
winter. One buck is good-sized, about one hundred-thirty
pounds, the other smaller, about one hundred. We hang them
from the rafters to finish the bleeding and to ready for
skinning. Knives come out now, knives that were sharpened the
day before or that morning, and we begin skinning the hide
from the still warm bodies that seem smaller now than on the
beach, even smaller than when they lay in the skiff.
We slide the knife under the fat of the skin as the other hand
pulls the hide taut. Out of habit, we try to keep the hides
intact, though we have no plans to tan them. We work fast,
speaking softly to each other, in low tones, or not at all;
though we are happy for the meat, and satisfied that the hunt
went well, we do not laugh. There is work to do, and these
bodies, less than two hours ago, were walking the beach.
When
the hide is finally off, through a combination of cutting and
then pulling it over the head, the deer becomes meat. I am
glad to feel this sudden distance. But it is not the same as
when cattle become meat. The old bulls are so massive, that
once inert, quartered and hung, it is impossible to imagine
them again as living beings. The deer, even as they hang,
are still lithe, fragile, the muscle between the bones is
spare, efficient. We will let the meat hang for four days to
season. I consider for the first time how good it will taste.
*
* * *
Before
I began to hunt deer, I saw the winterkill every spring,
sometimes just a few, sometimes many---the flesh gone, just the
hair and hide tenting over bones, and some just-new fawns. Too
many deer for the island, too much winter. Last fall, before
the snow, a large herd of deer began a swim, a swim from
somewhere too far away. The weather got bad as it often does in
September, the seas heaved, and somewhere out in the Shelikof
Strait it happened. They washed up just a mile from our place,
ninety of them, strewn along the beach for a half mile, locked
in the contortions of their drowning.
Annie Dillard has written, “Creation carries on with an
intricacy unfathomable, and apparently uncalled for.” Part of
that carrying on and that intricacy seems to be slaughter and
waste. I would stop it. I have tried in small ways: the
oystercatchers on my beach the year of the oil spill, the murre
that winter.
We
were traveling in the skiff on the way to the village store.
Goldeneyes, a few puffins, murres were busy with morning
feedings. Then, overhead, an eagle dropped from the sky and
snatched a murre from the water just feet beside us, then rose
up into the air, the bird still struggling in its talons.
Shocked, we watched the eagle ride the currents against the
mountain to lift the heavy prize to its nest. Then, in a move
that was equally instinctive, Duncan grabbed the rifle in the
bow and fired it vertically in an attempt to---I don’t know
what. I don’t think he did either. We both just felt the need to
do something. The eagle, startled by the sound, released
its hold and the murre dropped, slowly tumbling down the
hillside to the beach below. We had not planned this, but we
felt a desperate need to rescue this bird, more than that, a
responsibility, because now we were a part of the whole snarled
web. With the eagle circling us, screeching, we raced to the
beach, tenderly lifted the bird. His sides were pierced and
bleeding, eyes open, but he was still alive, struggling. He
could live. We could nurse him. We brought him back to our
island, found a cardboard box, lined it with grass, then
waited.
The
ending is no surprise, how we found him the next morning, how
impossible and wrong the whole thing was from the beginning.
The eaglets went hungry, our consciences were not assuaged; the
murre’s death was wasted. The universe would not be so tinkered
with.
*
* * *
Eight days after the hunt, we are having roast for dinner. The
package we took from the freezer said “deer roast,” not venison.
We never call it venison. There is no living being with that
name. We do not pretend---we have killed a deer and now we will
eat it. It is tender, though a touch gamey. With potatoes and
carrots and homemade bread, it is a modest feast, and we begin
by saying grace. We are not thanking the deer, but the giver of
the deer.
I
have come to this: in this world, death in any form is ugly,
brutal, and unnatural. We must not expect otherwise. When we do,
we get strange visions, like the one articulated by Cleveland
Amory, the founder of the Fund for Animals. In the June 1992
issue of Sierra Magazine, he describes the utopia he
would create if he were ruler of the world as a place where
animals would be protected from people, and from one another as
well. In this predator-less economy, the overpopulation and
starvation that might result would be eradicated through
“sterilization or implant.”
If
I were ruler in a world of my making, I would do much more, and
much less----the coyote resting beside the lamb, the eagle and
murre feeding together. And if that, then this--a man and a
woman walking the early morning beaches, and deer walking with
them. Or deer, smelling their scent, darting up the banks, and
making it, all of them, to safety.
|